Home
  Contests and Giveaways
  Hobby Headlines
  Hobby Articles
  Box Breaks
  Product Reviews
  Collector Corner
  Sports Cards
  Non-Sports Cards
  Collectibles
  Forums
  Gallery
  Blogs
  Chat
  Trivia
  FAQ
  Contact Us
  NPN Offers
  Price Guides
  Grading
  Supplies
  Software
  Card Calendar
  Show Calendar
  Team Addresses
  Collecting Tips
  Marketplace
  eBay
Custom Search

Welcome, Guest. The Collector Zone is a free community for trading card collectors - both sports and non-sports. There are forums for all of the major sports, non-sports, autographs and other hobby-related information. In addition, there are areas to trade, buy and sell with other collectors. Our members have now completed over 48,125 collector-to-collector transactions using our easy-to-use Transaction Manager.

With over 30,500 collectors and over 2,750,000 posts, there's plenty of ways to get involved with the other members - either in discussions or with trading. So, are you ready to join and start meeting other collectors?

If you're not a member, click here: Register


If you're already a member, login here:


 
Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

> Card Grading - PSA/BGS/others??? Who's best?

Bobcats110
post Sep 1 2012, 01:28 AM
Post #1

Bobcats110
Group Icon

Posts: 300
Joined: 17-June 09
From: Keller, TX
First Name: Mark
Transactions: 37
(View: Pending | Failed)

eBay: Bobcats110


View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


I have about 10 cards that I want to get graded in order to sell them. Beckett is in my backyard and they are having a grading open house at the end of the month, which removes my hesitation to mail the cards. However, I wondered if there is a better company to use, for whatever the reason, that using company A vs. company B and getting the best value out of the cards.

Is there any perception that having a PSA grade is better than Beckett or vice versa. Is there someone else I should be looking at?

Two are MJ rookies and another is the Bird/Irving AS/Johnson 1981 Rookie, so some key cards that I want to make sure get me maximum return.

If Becket is ok, the two Jordans are "pre-graded" by Beckett as 8 and 8.5...should I present them blind or keep them in those sleeves. Would there be any reason for the grades to differ this time around?

Thank you in advance for your opinions.



MLB Team:
NHL Team:
User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
northicehero99
post Sep 1 2012, 08:25 AM
Post #2

Legend
Group Icon

Posts: 35,062
Joined: 4-April 05
First Name: Brian
Transactions: 1505
(View: Pending | Failed)

eBay: northicehero99


OpenChecklist:
northicehero99

Awards:
Trader of the Year - 2007, 2008; Trader of the Month - Aug. '05, Oct. '06, Jan. '07, Jul. '07, January 2010 Pack Pull of the Month Member of trhe Month March 2012

View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


Mark, I think most people's perception is that Beckett is the best, then PSA, then others like KSA etc. However, I am sure you will get lots of different opinions. My problem with grading is that it is subjective to whomever is grading the card and how do I know the person doing it is an expert. What looks good to one person might be flawed to someone else. I have heard too many stories from people expecting big grades and not getting them and also the opposite I have seen slabbed "mint" 9.0/9.5 cards that have prints spots or other flaws which make me question how they got the grades with those flaws and no notation on the flaw.

As for the two cards already graded, I think leaving them in the encasement leaves a bias torwards what they were previously graded, however taking them out could go either way and you might end up with 7s rather than 9s, so that one is a tough call. Guess it depends on whether you want to risk getting better or worse grades.

I don't get cards graded so I am not an expert so this is just my opinions and experiences. I know redwing40 sent stuff in recently, so you might want to see what his opinion is of Beckett.



MLB Team:
NFL Team:
NHL Team:
User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
aceecards
post Sep 1 2012, 11:39 AM
Post #3

Legend
Group Icon
Group Icon

Posts: 69,447
Joined: 23-April 05
First Name: Steve
Transactions: 965
(View: Pending | Failed)

Awards:
2012 Battle Royal Champion 2009 Best Autograph Card 2008, 2009 and 2010 Best Overall Collection 2007 Trade of the Year Trader of the Month - Oct. '05, Aug. '06, Aug. '07

View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


personally use beckett.

and yes leave the raw pregrades bagegd and tagged


Collector Zone Team
user posted image

The New Bucket!
newer bucket

MLB Team:
NBA Team:
NFL Team:
NHL Team:
User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Iplayfootball_90
post Sep 1 2012, 12:39 PM
Post #4

Hot Fuzz
Group Icon

Posts: 13,180
Joined: 13-June 06
Transactions: 138
(View: Pending | Failed)

Restrictions:
Current Transactions Only


View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


Beckett definitely.


Though PSA isn't bad either.


user posted image

User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
redwing40
post Sep 1 2012, 01:00 PM
Post #5

MVP
Group Icon
Group Icon

Posts: 4,656
Joined: 20-April 11
Transactions: 124
(View: Pending | Failed)

View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


Beckett hands down as I use them and have 8 cards graded from them! Goodluck on the grades!


Collector Zone Team
user posted image

User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
redwing40
post Sep 1 2012, 01:05 PM
Post #6

MVP
Group Icon
Group Icon

Posts: 4,656
Joined: 20-April 11
Transactions: 124
(View: Pending | Failed)

View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


This is one of the better grades I have gotton back.....

user posted image

But one thing to make sure before you send any in, check them with a fine tooth comb, nic's on corners, edge's, surface, borders, look really hard to find anything wrong with them, one little thing will lower the grade, once slabbed, thats it, its marked! Goodluck!


Collector Zone Team
user posted image

User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
dodgerblue38501
post Sep 5 2012, 10:46 AM
Post #7

GO GATORS !!!
Group Icon
Group Icon

Posts: 5,957
Joined: 5-February 07
From: Mount Juliet, TN
First Name: Chad
Transactions: 186
(View: Pending | Failed)

eBay: cardguy37122


Awards:
2009 Must Read of the Year

View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


Beckett is better for modern cards (Chromes, RC Autos, etc). PSA is better for vintage stuff up through the early 80s like HOF RCs. SGC is the best for really old pre war stuff. The problem is that you need a yearly membership to submit cards to PSA. At least, I assume you still need one. I had one but let it expire a few years back. BGS should be fine for the cards you have although PSA would be just as good. Personally, I've never liked the idea of Beckett, who produces the price guide that is used as the industry standard, also being a grading company whose graded cards just happen to be valued higher than any other companies graded cards. Just a matter of preference I guess.


Collector Zone Team
user posted image

NOW COLLECTING:

FLORIDA GATORS FOOTBALL AUTOS & GU
(College Uniform ONLY)


SANDY KOUFAX: Vintage / GU / AUTOS

DARRYL STRAWBERRY: PATCHES & PATCH/AUTOS

MLB Team:
NFL Team:
User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Bobcats110
post Oct 3 2012, 11:39 PM
Post #8

Bobcats110
Group Icon

Posts: 300
Joined: 17-June 09
From: Keller, TX
First Name: Mark
Transactions: 37
(View: Pending | Failed)

eBay: Bobcats110


View Gallery

View Trading and Marketplace Topics

Create Transaction


Thanks everyone for the input. Really appreciate the insight, and Chad, nice analysis of who you think is better for what cards.



MLB Team:
NHL Team:
User is offlinePMProfile Card
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Reply to this topicTopic OptionsStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
 

Lo-Fi Version Time: 23rd October 2014 - 10:07 AM
  

Partner
Sportlots.com

Affiliate

Affiliate
BCW Supplies

 
 
 
Copyright 2000-2014 Trading Card Central. All rights reserved.   Advertise  Partners  Links  About Us  Contact Us